Dr.
Dave's answers to frequently-asked questions (FAQs),
mostly from the BD
CCB and AZB
discussion forums
maintained for the book: The
Illustrated Principles of Pool and Billiards
and the monthly Billiards
Digest "Illustrated Principles"
instructional articles
for more information, see Chapter 6 and Sections 7.06-7.08 in The Illustrated Principles of Pool and Billiards
Why do many top bankers use fast speed?
With faster speed, there is much less variation from table to table and from shot to shot.
Faster speed can also help reduce the chance for a double kiss at certain approach angles (see HSV B.34).
from Patrick Johnson:
Each bank shot is affected by
many variables, each of which changes the angle of rebound:
stickiness of:
-
rail cloth
- surface cloth
- balls
trueness of:
- rails
- surface
spin
on OB:
- sidespin
- follow/draw
The holy grail in banks is to eliminate as many variables as possible, and just about every one of these variables "flattens out" at higher speeds. Shooting at one hard speed eliminates the most variables so you don't have to shoot the same bank differently each time.
diamond systems for kick shots
How does the Diamond System work?
The simplest diamond system is the 1-rail through-diamond system.
The most famous"diamond system" is the three-rail "Corner 5" system. It is illustrated and explained, with examples, in TP 7.2 and in these articles: part 1 and part 2. Here's another useful resource.
The three-rail Corner-5, two-rail Plus-2, and "spot-on-the-wall" systems are described and demonstrated in NV B.35.
Here's an article on the Plus-2 system.
from DeadAim:
complete
"kicking academy" document describing and illustrating many diamond
systems for kick shots.
double kiss detection and avoidance with a cross-corner bank shot
How do you know if a bank shot will cause a double-kiss, and how can you avoid it?
See NV B.23. The video demonstrates an easy method to use to detect and avoid cross-corner bank double kisses.
HSV B.32 shows several techniques to avoid a double kiss with a cross-side bank shot.
HSV B.34 shows how to detect a double kiss when banking a ball frozen or close to the rail.
effects and factors to consider
What effects does one need to adjust for when aiming bank and kick shots?
The basic mirror (angle in equals angle out) systems provide a point of reference only. Your aim with a given shot depends on many effects. The effects that require aim adjustment include:
If one doesn't understand all of these effects, or have great intuition built up from years and years of mistakes, the mirror systems are not very useful.
from Patrick Johnson:
For kicks the important thing is what kind of "vertical spin" the CB has on it when it hits the rail:
- CB sliding when it hits the rail will rebound with no curve at the "mirror angle" (minus something for rail friction)
- CB with forward spin (including natural roll) when it hits the rail will curve longer than the mirror angle
- CB with backspin when it hits the rail will curve shorter than the mirror angle
How much longer or shorter the CB rebounds (with forward spin or backspin) depends on how much spin is on the CB* and how much friction there is between the CB and the cloth.
For banks the important thing is how much vertical spin is on the OB when it hits the rail. This can only be controlled by hitting harder or softer (harder = less or no forward spin; softer = more forward spin). This is also why hitting harder shortens bank angles.
*: How much spin is on the CB depends on: - how hard it's hit - how high it's hit - how far it is from the rail when it's hit - how much friction there is between CB/cloth
mirror system for shallow-angle, rolling kick shots
Does the basic mirror system apply for shallow angle, rolling kick shots?
from
Bob_Jewett:
The "bounce" for a shallow-angle rolling shot is
only about 70% of the incoming angle. That is, the ball tends to go more parallel
to the cushion than the mirror system says. How much of the 30% discount applies
depends on the spin and speed on the cue ball, of course.
Is spin transfer required to make certain bank shots?
Yes. See NV B.20 for two important examples. For more information, and another example, see my March '07 article.
spot-on-the-wall kicking system
How do "spot-on-the-wall" kicking systems work?
The three-rail Corner-5, two-rail Plus-2, and one-rail kick "spot-on-the-wall" systems are described and demonstrated in NV B.35.
two-rail parallel-line kick shot
Dr.
Dave, I have been practicing the 2-rail parallel line kick shots you show in your
book on pages 229 & 230 and demonstrated in NV
7.9. It works fine if I set up the balls similar to what you show in your
book but I am having difficulty envisioning the same shot from other set ups.
I don't think I fully understand how to determine the center line between the
2 parallel lines. Can you elaborate on this idea?
Unfortunately, the action of this shot depends on English (running vs. reverse), shot speed, and table (especially cushion) conditions. Obviously, when practicing, you need to try to use consistent English and speed on a given table to see how the cue ball responds at different angles.
Concerning how to aim, I usually do a trial and error sort of thing where I first take a guess at the aiming line direction, lining up the cue stick through the cue ball in this direction. Then I visualize the direction the cue ball will come of the first rail. For a medium speed, center ball hit, the angle off the rail is close to the angle into the rail. This lets me estimate where the cue ball will hit the second rail. Moving the cue stick to that point, keeping it parallel to the initial aiming line, will estimate the final direction. Then I adjust the aiming line direction as necessary based on how the estimated final direction compares with the desired target direction. I continue this until I am happy with the final direction. This goes quickly after you get the hang of it. Also, the final line will usually come up a little short (e.g., see Figure 7.21 on p. 230), so I adjust my aim a little to account for this; but again, this will depend on the table conditions and how you shoot the shot. If you use running English, you will also need to get a feel for how it affects the angle off the first rail.
I know all of that sounds complicated, but I hope it helps some. I, for one, don't expect to have great accuracy with this type of shot. Although, it comes in handy when I get badly snookered by a well-played opponent safety or by very poor position play on my part.
Bob_Jewett
wrote:
.. the "Amazing Double-mirror Image Method" or ADIM for
short ... is explained on the second page of http://www.sfbilliards.com/articles/2004-07.pdf.
Mostly, it gives you a very easy way to put up a target ball exactly where the
real ball would appear for a perfect mirror system. ... This lets you see immediately
how pitifully awful the two-rail mirror system is, but it also allows you to try
to find out where it does work and maybe how to modify it so it works for more
cases.